Complete Works › Essay: philosophy and politics

A Remarkable Document

Type
Essay: philosophy and politics
Written
Unknown
First published
The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1917
US status
Full text on this site

About this work

A review of a temperance essay by the novelist Booth Tarkington on why men drink, told through the story of an artist friend who gave it up. Lovecraft, a strict teetotaller and supporter of Prohibition, welcomes it as a common-sense argument against drink.

Full text

As first printed in The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1917. About 486 words.

Printed as a section of the column “In the Editor’s Study”, under the heading “A Remarkable Document”.

Friends of the Temperance cause, to whom the existence of the drink habit seems as inexplicable as it is lamentable and criminal, will take phenomenal interest in the article by Mr. Booth Tarkington entitled “Nipskillions”, which appeared in The American Magazine for January, and which was reprinted in The National Enquirer for April 12. This terse little essay, which takes its name from the slang word applied in certain circles to a man who has turned from drink to temperance through satiation, tells in remarkably vivid fashion of the precise sensations of the drinker, and of the damnably seductive false cheer of the cup which leads in so many cases to complete mental, moral and physical degradation. Denying the incurable addiction of the average drinker to his poison, the article throws an unusually grave responsibility upon the persistent tippler.

Mr. Tarkington, relating the true story of an artist friend who saved himself at the last moment from the clutches of alcoholism, makes a notable contribution to the temperance cause; not only through the authenticity of his account, but from the fact that he writes not as a moral or religious doctrinaire, but as a rational and discerning man of the world. He gives an infallible indication of the new temperance movement - a movement which has its foundation in common sense rather than abstract principle.

According to Mr. Tarkington, the prime incentive to drink is the desire for a greater degree of enjoyment and relaxation than is compatible with the normal mental and physical condition. In other words, human creatures long atavistically for the levity of an inferior state, and wish to throw off artificially the burden of dignity with which evolution from the simian type has invested them. If this theory be universally true, then the drink problem is much more difficult of solution than as if it were merely an ingrained social custom. No one can deny that life in conventionally civilised communities is dull and monotonous to the point of loathsomeness; and if this basic ennui be so potent a factor in the desire for liquor, then we cannot expect to banish the evil till we have found some means of brightening the gloom which causes it. One of the greatest problems of the day then, is a cure for the unutterable world-weariness which afflicts mankind; or if its complete cure be impossible, its alleviation. Not that the ordinary forces of temperance reform should be less active, but that we should be less Spartan and Puritan in our worship of duty at the expense of legitimate pleasure. It behooves the reformer to appear in a less forbidding guise, and to prefer grace to austerity in prosecuting his endeavours. Drink, we know, is abnormal; but if we are to banish this abnormality we must likewise banish the equal abnormality of excessive mental sabbatarianism. “Virtue itself offends”, said an old writer, “when coupled with forbidding manners.”

Source. Wikisource transcription of the original printing, checked against its page scans (2 pages): The Conservative (Lovecraft)/July 1917/In the Editor's Study. The page images of The Conservative on Wikisource (Index: The Conservative.pdf) are a later typed reproduction of the issues, not a photographic facsimile; the text follows that reproduction. Original spelling and punctuation are kept; 0 evident errors corrected.

Copyright. First published in the United States in 1917. US works published in 1930 or earlier are in the public domain. Status may differ in other countries. Works rights log (CSV).

Sources. hplovecraft.com (after Joshi, Collected Essays). Status explained on Rights & Sources.