Complete Works › Essay: amateur journalism

Amateurdom

Type
Essay: amateur journalism
Written
Unknown
First published
The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1919
US status
Full text on this site

About this work

A survey of recent amateur papers, praising the general standard of the United Amateur Press Association’s journals and mourning the death of the amateur writer Helene Hoffman Cole.

Full text

As first printed in The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1919. About 477 words.

Printed as a section of the column “In the Editor’s Study”, under the heading “Amateurdom”.

Judging from the quality of most of the United papers which have lately reached The Conservative’s desk, amateur journalism has now attained a cultural level not before touched since the later eighties and early nineties. At what other period in recent years has the space of six months afforded such a display of wit and intellect as is included in the journals appearing since the dawn of 1919? To mention The United Amateur would be redundant. Under the McGeoch regime that organ is wholly beyond praise; a model which our competitors both envy and emulate. But the uniformity with which individual publications maintain high standards, is as remarkable as it is encouraging. In steady succession have arrived The Recruiter, Pine Cones, The Hellenian, Corona, and The Piper; the last named of which comes just in time for admiring recognition in these columns.

Pine Cones and Corona represent a departure from conventional typography which establishes an excellent precedent. Too much importance has been attached to the printing-press in modern amateurdom, and it is gratifying to observe that editors are beginning to realise the more basic object of literature—the diffusion of thought irrespective of medium. It is noteworthy that these non-printed journals occupy the highest rank, intellectually, amongst the season’s products. If this worthy example is followed as it should be, our circle will be enriched by the utterances of many learned and cultured members hitherto inarticulate through inability to issue printed papers.

The untimely death of Mrs. Helene Hoffman Cole is a source of lamentation throughout amateurdom. In the loss of so gifted and diligent a worker, the cause suffers immeasurably. United members perused with melancholy interest the May official organ, which contained numerous tributes to Mrs. Cole, and which forms a literary monument to her honoured memory. Of corresponding value will be the forthcoming Hellenian, commenced by Mrs. Cole but shortly before her demise, and completed by Mr. Cole as an affectionate memorial.

That amateurs of intelligence are not indifferent to man’s chief solace and source of inspiration, is well demonstrated by the almost simultaneous appearance of two poems in praise of books; one by Mr. Kleiner in The Piper, the other by Mr. Goodenough in these columns. Both pieces represent genius of a high order, and both will awaken an universal response from those readers who have weighed carefully the relative value of life’s various blessings.

Mr. John Milton Samples’ regularly issued monthly, The Silver Clarion, is an amateur journal whose progress and development should be watched with interest. At present censured by certain critics for its atmosphere of sanctity and unsophistication, it has lately enlarged its editorial staff and embarked upon a course of steady artistic development. Its policy, however, will not be altered; and it will remain as a sturdy exponent of honest Anglo-Saxon virtue in an age tainted with degeneracy and continental ideals.

Source. Wikisource transcription of the original printing, checked against its page scans (4 pages): The Conservative (Lovecraft)/July 1919/In the Editor's Study. The page images of The Conservative on Wikisource (Index: The Conservative.pdf) are a later typed reproduction of the issues, not a photographic facsimile; the text follows that reproduction. Original spelling and punctuation are kept; 1 evident error corrected: “devlopment” → “development”.

Copyright. First published in the United States in 1919. US works published in 1930 or earlier are in the public domain. Status may differ in other countries. Works rights log (CSV).

Sources. hplovecraft.com (after Joshi, Collected Essays). Status explained on Rights & Sources.