Complete Works › Essay: amateur journalism

For Official Editor—Anne Tillery Renshaw

Type
Essay: amateur journalism
Written
Unknown
First published
The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1919
US status
Full text on this site

About this work

A campaign editorial for the 1919 United Amateur Press Association election, backing Anne Tillery Renshaw for Official Editor and attacking her opponent and the faction behind him.

Full text

As first printed in The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1919. About 809 words.

Printed as a section of the column “In the Editor’s Study”, under the heading “For Official Editor—Anne Tillery Renshaw”.

Associational politics, happily dormant since the sordid period of 1916, has once more raised its sinister head to challenge the achievements of those who have laboured in behalf of the United’s evolution; and distasteful though the subject may be to the true friend of amateur literature, prompt discussion is necessary if the work of recent terms is not to be undone. Out of its native darkness after a welcome absence of three years comes the turbulent Cleveland element (apologies to Mr. Samuel Loveman—shining exception!) with its attending train of blatant vulgarity and innuendo, bent on seating in the Official Editor’s chair a candidate of such conspicuous unfitness for power that his defeat becomes a public duty on the part of those who cherish the progress and paramountcy of the United.

Direct comment on The Cleveland Sun and what it represents is obviously impossible in these columns, because of the boorishly sneering attitude which that contemporary has chosen to adopt toward The Conservative and his efforts in amateurdom. Comment, under these circumstances, could not but reflect a certain amount of personal disgust and purely subjective opposition. But no such inhibitions of good taste restrain the pen which would point out reasons why one William J. Dowdell of Bearcat notoriety must not be allowed to acquire the enormous—almost supreme—influence us a molder of policy which goes with the Official Editorship of the United Amateur Press Association.

Mr. Dowdell, ever since he became old enough to entertain opinions of his own, has consistently favoured the cruder and less desirable side of amateur journalism. His bitter and puerile hostility to those improvements of 1915–16 which placed the United upon its present cultural basis, and his very singular oversights as Secretary in mailing proxy ballots, are too well known to require citation; while his more recent complete devotion to the National speaks for itself. The absurd anti-Campbell outbursts appearing in the Bearcat three years ago worked greatly to the detriment of the United, and gave the National ground for one of its illiberal attacks upon us. As a publisher—and it is as a publisher par excellence that he makes his appeal for votes—no one can fail to see that Mr. Dowdell’s claims far exceed his accomplishments. He is indeed, a veritable Prince of Broken Promises. Members of the United who contributed cash for the co-operative paper he was to issue in 1916, are still awaiting the arrival of that paper; meanwhile wondering why their literary matter was pirated by Mr. Dowdell’s personal Bearcat, and why their money has not been refunded!

Mr. Dowdell glibly pledges himself to a continuance of the McGeoch editorial policy if elected. Do his past and present performances warrant such a prediction? Since actions speak louder than words, if appears to The Conservative that the election of Mr. Dowdell would result in an abrupt drop in the official organ from classical to plebeian standards. Mr. Dowdell is clever, and could go far in literature if he chose, but up to now he has shown no inclination to succeed except on a very low cultural plane—the plane of commercial “yellow” newspaper journalism. His artistic birth has not yet take place. It is probably no exaggeration to say that the Bearcat and Sun, as now conducted, are fair specimens of the grade of official organ which Mr. Dowdell would give us—when he might condescend to give us any. Need more be said? Forewarned is forearmed!

The vote of every well-wisher of the United Amateur Press Association should be cast for Mrs. Anne Tillery Renshaw as Official Editor. Mrs. Renshaw, now an Instructor in Pennsylvania State College, and a reciter and poetess of repute, heels no introduction to amateurs. Her work us a recruiter has been the greatest constructive force in the United during recent years, and of available candidates she alone is able to maintain the McGeoch editorial standards. Under her guidance the official organ can continue to act as a nucleus for the intellectual activities of the Association, without it, the organ must inevitably lose prestige, and the best elements of our membership become dormant or disappear entirely from amateurdom. Few realize how much of next year’s programme hinges absolutely upon Mrs. Renshaw’s election.

It would be interesting to analyse the motives of those “dark forces” which have set up a candidate in opposition to Mrs. Renshaw. Significant indeed is their close connexion with the rival society—Mr. Dowdell is now a National member only, and has not been in the United for a period of more than two years. These Clevelandites come to us from the National with plans which if successful will tend to submerge our Association and restore to the senior organisation its long-coveted ancient supremacy. Shall we not rally to the defence of the United with votes for Mrs. Renshaw as Official Editor?

Source. Wikisource transcription of the original printing, checked against its page scans (4 pages): The Conservative (Lovecraft)/July 1919/In the Editor's Study. The page images of The Conservative on Wikisource (Index: The Conservative.pdf) are a later typed reproduction of the issues, not a photographic facsimile; the text follows that reproduction. Original spelling and punctuation are kept; 1 evident error corrected: “distateful” → “distasteful”.

Copyright. First published in the United States in 1919. US works published in 1930 or earlier are in the public domain. Status may differ in other countries. Works rights log (CSV).

Sources. hplovecraft.com (after Joshi, Collected Essays). Status explained on Rights & Sources.