Complete Works › Essay: amateur journalism

Ward Phillips Replies

Type
Essay: amateur journalism
Written
Unknown
First published
The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1918
US status
Full text on this site

About this work

A joke at Lovecraft’s own expense. A reviewer had compared his poem “Astrophobos”, printed under the pen name Ward Phillips, unfavourably with Rheinhart Kleiner’s “Ruth”; here “Mr. Phillips” replies by offering a poem in Kleiner’s simple, tender manner. The poem, “Grace”, has its own page.

Full text

As first printed in The Conservative (Lovecraft’s own amateur journal, Providence, Rhode Island), in the column “In the Editor’s Study”, July 1918. About 82 words.

Printed as a section of the column “In the Editor’s Study”, under the heading “Ward Phillips Replies”.

The Conservative acknowledges a communication from Ward Phillips, Esq., whose recent ulalumish poem entitled “Astrophobos” was so unfavourably contrasted with Mr. Kleiner’s “Ruth” by a reviewer in the May United Amateur. Mr. Phillips would make it plain, that if he so desired he could work with perfect ease in a simpler, tenderer, and more popular medium; and as an answer to his critics he has graciously favoured this office with the following effusion, in the metre and manner of his distinguished contemporary:

The poem that followed, “Grace”, has its own page: Grace.

Source. Wikisource transcription of the original printing, checked against its page scans (5 pages): The Conservative (Lovecraft)/July 1918/In the Editor's Study. The page images of The Conservative on Wikisource (Index: The Conservative.pdf) are a later typed reproduction of the issues, not a photographic facsimile; the text follows that reproduction. Original spelling and punctuation are kept; 2 evident errors corrected: “unfavourubly” → “unfavourably”; “and us an answer” → “and as an answer”.

Copyright. First published in the United States in 1918. US works published in 1930 or earlier are in the public domain. Status may differ in other countries. Works rights log (CSV).

Sources. Identified from The Conservative (Wikisource, scan-backed): a headed section of “In the Editor’s Study”. Status explained on Rights & Sources.